|
|
|
|
| Group
test: Stereo CD and amp combos |
| Arcam,
Cambridge Audio, Denon and Marantz |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
HIFI REVIEWS 18 / 02 / 06 |
Group
test: Stereo CD and amp combos
By Shaun Marin
Stereo is dead, right? No, wrong, wrong and wrong again! Good
old two-channel hi-fi is most definitely alive and very well. And
we're not just talking about the retro-vinyl revolution or in the
esoteric high-end sphere where people spend upwards of a few grand
on a CD player. The audiophile-on-a-budget is also still being catered
for, and as this collection of dedicated two-channel amplifiers
and CD spinners shows, there's plenty of choice out there.
Whether it's
a combo for under £500 or more refined high resolution-capable
kit costing twice that, there's something in the market for everyone.
True, the last couple of years have been a little bit quieter in
this area, but that now seems to be changing with a host of new
products from manufactures who have come back into the market and
some from those that never left it. And all it takes to keep it
this way is for enough people to forsake the wrong path of playing
CDs on their budget DVD players, and embrace the true way of stereo!
You know it makes sense. |
| |
|
| Arcam DiVA
CD73 and DiVA A65+ |
|
Cards on
the table time: my first proper hi-fi was an Arcam double act just
like this one in many respects… but completely different in
others. It's similar in that there are certain Arcam elements that
have survived recent changes - anyone used to the old Alpha kit
will recognise the layout and displays - but gone is the cheap-feeling
battleship grey plastic fascias, replaced with a considerably more
attractive metal finish (available in black or silver). The build
quality has moved to match the changing look - it may not be up
to the brand's FMJ range but for the money it's impressive.
It's not just
the styling that's gone upmarket though, as the sound quality has
also improved with recent technological developments and research
conducted into higher priced kit. The CD player in particular performs
very well, with an open, direct approach to sound reproduction that
immediately draws you into the music and wins a place in our heart.
The A65+ amplifier
has been around for a good few years now, but it still performs
well for its price. Although, compared to the best of the competition
here, particularly the Denon powerhouse, but also the Marantz PM4001OSE,
it lacks a little bit of punch for our liking.
As a double
act they perform well, but as with Eric Morecombe and Ernie Wise
you feel that one of them is the real star while the other one could
do with a makeover.
Overview
Price: £420/£400
Size (WxHxD): CD 43x29x9cm, amp 43x29x9cm
Weight: CD 4.6kg amp 5.4kg
SACD playback: No
Amp power rating: 40 watts per channel
Analogue inputs: 4
Phono stage: Yes
Headphone socket: Yes
|
 |
Verdict
Plus points
Good looking duo with the top notch CD player really doing the
business with stereo
Minus points
The amp lacks the dynamics to really get excited, particularly
with the Denon costing only a bit more |
|
|
| |
| Cambridge
Audio Azur 640C V2 and Azur 640A |
 |
A few years
ago, two events changed the budget two-channel market for ever:
the DVD explosion and the complete turnaround at Cambridge Audio.
The British company went from being the Richer Sounds house brand
to a serious option for the audiophile on a budget, producing top-notch
kit that many major manufacturers struggled to match for the money.
Still, the company
hasn't rested on its laurels, and this latest incarnation of its
affordable hi-fi family is better than ever. This double act isn't
quite entry level, as it sits just above the brand's 540 components,
but it's certainly far from expensive. Not that you would be able
to tell that from looking, because in terms of styling and build
quality this system gives all the others here a serious run for
their money.
The same is
true in sound quality, and you have to keep asking how they do it
for the cash, or lack of it. The answer that they build the kit
in China doesn't hold water as so do most of the other manufacturers.
There's an openness to the sound that belies the price point, and,
getting away from money for a moment, it offers all-round excellent
sound reproduction full stop. The tricky areas of female vocals
and complex classical concerts are both handled with flair, and
every CD we played on this system came to life before our ears.
Seriously impressive
kit, that manages to cement Cambridge Audio's reputation as the
first stop on many a price-conscious audiophile's shopping list.
Overview
Price: £250/£250
Size (WxHxD): CD 43x31x7cm, amp 43x32x10cm
Weight: CD 4.6kg, amp 7kg
SACD playback: No
Amp power rating: 65 watts per channel
Analogue inputs: 5
Phono stage: No
Headphone socket: Yes |
 |
Verdict
Plus points
Fantastic build quality; great price, wonderful performance
Minus points
No phono stage, but that's about it |
|
|
| |
| Denon
DCD-1500AE and PMA-1500AE |
 |
Denon's
move back into affordable hi-fi is an interesting example of how
the industry is once more coming over to two-channel. This is its
most affordable current combination, and one that has gradually
filtered down from the very high-end products that it has continued
to make in Japan. Still, this combination comes in at the top end
of our little group of two-part, two-channel challengers, and to
be honest it looks like it. Whether it's the larger-than-life CD
player or the built-like a brick outhouse amplifier, you know you
have your hands on some serious products here.
Build quality
is sublime, with top-notch speaker terminals, excellent remote controls
and fascias that fairly scream high-end. In fact, the only thing
that doesn't scream is the audio performance, which is easily the
best here and has a deftness of touch that none of the competition
can match (although to be fair, two of them sell at half this price).
This combo is
also the only one here to offer SACD replay, but we'll concentrate
on the standard version for the sake of fairness, even though the
high resolution performance is first rate. This combo just kept
demanding we play music on it: whether it was the latest Cat Power
offering or the Ramones' Greatest Hits, the Denon duo blew us away
with a deft combination of subtly and powerful attack.
Yes, it's the
most expensive kit here, but if your budget can stretch to it, then
your ears will love you forever.
Overview
Price: £500/£550
Size (WxHxD): CD 43x14x33cm, amp 43x40x13cm
Weight: CD 7.6kg amp 14.6kg
SACD playback: Yes
Amp power rating: 70 watts per channel
Analogue inputs: 5
Phono stage: Yes
Headphone socket: Yes |
 |
Verdict
Plus points
Superb build and truly excellent sound
Minus points
It's the most expensive here, so therefore its price acts against
it |
|
|
| |
| Marantz CD5001OSE and PM4001OSE |
 |
All hail the comeback kids.
For a few years there, Marantz shunned the affordable stereo market
in the same way that supermodels tend to shun an audiophile when
he manages to sneak into a night club. But the legendary stereo
brand is back, and back with not just one entry-level CD player
and amplifier, but two! Like the Cambridge kit here, there's another
cheaper family member for those with budgetary restrictions, but
these OSE versions come in at a very reasonable £500 for the
pair. For this you get an amplifier and a CD player with such niceties
as an improved power supply and improved capacitors - plus some
general hi-fi tweaking.
On the looks front we have to say
that while we love the styling of the CD player, we don't think
it quite works on the amplifier. And while the metal finish is still
a bonus at this price, neither unit feels quite as solid as the
similarly priced Cambridge. But, it's all about sound quality at
the end of the day, and in that area of expertise Marantz is still
the daddy. The combination offers a performance with plenty of drive,
attack and a toe-tapping approach to music that keeps you coming
back for more.
This stylish
combination well and truly puts Marantz back on the affordable hi-fi
map, and is worth serious consideration if you are in the market
to bring your CD collection back to life.
Overview
Price: £250/£250
Size (WxHxD): CD 44x32x9cm, amp 44x34x16cmcm
Weight: CD 3.7kg amp 6kg
SACD playback: No
Amp power rating: 55 watts per channel
Analogue inputs: 5
Phono stage: Yes
Headphone socket: Yes
|
 |
Verdict
Plus points
Dynamic, enjoyable approach to music, solid build quality, has
a phono stage for connecting a turntable
Minus points
Styling may not appeal if that's important to you |
|
|
| |
| Group
test verdict
It wouldn't be an understatement to say we were blown away by each
and every one of the combinations in this group. The standard across
the board was highly impressive, and really puts out to pasture
any doubts about the strength of the affordable two-channel arena
- at least in terms of the quality of the products available. The
Quad 12L (£500) loudspeakers that we used with each of the
products enjoyed every minute of the workout, and have rarely sounded
so good with price-comparable kit.
At the lower end of the
price bracket it was a tough battle between the Marantz and Cambridge
Audio pairings, with the Marantz doing better on the feature front
but the Cambridge kit just winning out in terms of sound quality
and build. However, anyone considering a purchase should certainly
check out both, as the slightly different sounds may appeal to different
people.
The Arcam kit
also sounds excellent and it retains a place in my heart and a tonal
balance I'll always feel at home with. However, the new Denon range
beats it in terms of features, build and overall sonic output, and
it looks like the Japanese company's stereo resurgence is keeping
up its head of steam.
|
|
|